Consensus-based Forecasting: Definition, Process, Benefits, and Business Examples

Updated May 8, 2023

Published May 8, 2023


I. Introduction

Definition of consensus forecasting

Consensus forecasting (also called consensus-based forecasting) is a collaborative process that involves gathering and synthesizing input from multiple stakeholders to arrive at a shared forecast for a specific business outcome. This approach is particularly useful when it comes to making important business decisions that can impact a company's bottom line, such as sales forecasts, budget planning, and resource allocation.

Importance of consensus forecasting for business decision-making

At ifm Supply Chain, we believe that consensus forecasting is a critical tool for business success. By leveraging the diverse perspectives of different stakeholders, businesses can generate more accurate forecasts, mitigate individual biases, and arrive at better-informed decisions. Additionally, the process of consensus forecasting can foster enhanced communication and collaboration among teams, leading to a more cohesive and productive work environment

In the following sections, we'll explore the benefits of consensus forecasting, the process involved in this approach, real-world examples of successful implementation, and how it differs from other forecasting methods. By the end of this article, you'll have a comprehensive understanding of consensus forecasting and its potential impact on your business.

II. Benefits of Consensus Forecasting

Improved accuracy

By gathering input from multiple stakeholders, businesses can generate more accurate forecasts that take into account a range of perspectives and factors. This can lead to better predictions of business outcomes, more effective resource allocation, and ultimately, improved bottom-line results.

Mitigation of individual biases

When individuals make forecasts independently, they can be subject to cognitive biases that can skew their predictions. Consensus forecasting helps to mitigate these biases by encouraging stakeholders to challenge each other's assumptions, ask critical questions, and arrive at a shared forecast that reflects the collective expertise of the group.

More informed decision-making

Consensus forecasting provides decision-makers with a more comprehensive understanding of the factors that influence a particular business outcome. By taking into account a range of perspectives, businesses can make more informed decisions that are less likely to overlook important factors or unforeseen risks.

Enhanced communication and collaboration

The process of consensus forecasting can foster communication and collaboration among stakeholders, leading to a more cohesive and productive work environment. By encouraging stakeholders to work together towards a common goal, consensus forecasting can help to break down silos and build stronger cross-functional relationships.

III. Consensus Forecasting Process

The consensus forecasting process involves several key steps that enable businesses to arrive at a shared forecast for a specific outcome. These steps include:

  • Define the objective: Clearly define the objective of the forecast, including the outcome being predicted, the time horizon, and any relevant constraints or assumptions.
  • Gather input: Gather input from a diverse group of stakeholders, including subject matter experts, analysts, and decision-makers. Encourage stakeholders to challenge assumptions and ask critical questions.
  • Synthesize input: Synthesize the input from stakeholders to arrive at a shared forecast that reflects the collective expertise of the group.
  • Validate the forecast: Validate the forecast by testing it against historical data, comparing it to alternative scenarios, and identifying any potential weaknesses or uncertainties.
  • Communicate and monitor: Communicate the forecast to relevant stakeholders and monitor its accuracy over time, updating the forecast as new information becomes available.

Effective communication and collaboration are critical to the success of the consensus forecasting process. By fostering open communication and encouraging stakeholders to challenge each other's assumptions, businesses can arrive at a more accurate and robust forecast that reflects the collective expertise of the group.

Of course, there are potential challenges that can arise during the consensus forecasting process, such as conflicting opinions or limited data availability. However, these challenges can be overcome by establishing clear ground rules, providing training on effective communication and collaboration, and leveraging technology to facilitate the process. By doing so, businesses can maximize the benefits of consensus forecasting and make more informed decisions that drive success.

IV. Examples of Successful Consensus Forecasting in Business

Consensus forecasting has been successfully implemented by a range of companies across different industries. Here are a few real-world examples:

  • Coca-Cola: Coca-Cola uses a consensus forecasting approach to generate accurate sales forecasts for their products. By leveraging input from multiple stakeholders across the organization, including sales teams, distributors, and retailers, Coca-Cola has been able to improve their sales forecasting accuracy and reduce errors.
  • Ford: Ford uses a consensus forecasting approach to forecast demand for their vehicles. By incorporating input from sales teams, marketing teams, and supply chain teams, Ford has been able to improve their forecasting accuracy and better anticipate shifts in consumer demand.
  • Procter & Gamble: Procter & Gamble uses a consensus forecasting approach to forecast demand for their products across multiple regions and product lines. By gathering input from multiple stakeholders, including sales teams, supply chain teams, and marketing teams, Procter & Gamble has been able to generate more accurate and reliable forecasts, leading to improved inventory management and reduced stock-outs.

Lessons learned from these examples include the importance of establishing clear objectives, fostering open communication and collaboration among stakeholders, and leveraging technology to facilitate the process. By doing so, businesses can improve their forecasting accuracy, make more informed decisions, and ultimately drive success.

V. Consensus Forecasting: Advantages and Disadvantages

Advantages of consensus forecasting

  • Improved accuracy: By leveraging the expertise of multiple stakeholders, consensus forecasting can lead to more accurate forecasts that reflect a broader range of perspectives.
  • Mitigation of individual biases: Consensus forecasting can help mitigate individual biases that may arise in individual forecasting, such as overconfidence or confirmation bias.
  • More informed decision-making: Consensus forecasting can lead to more informed decision-making by providing decision-makers with a more comprehensive understanding of the factors that may impact the outcome being forecasted.

Disadvantages of consensus forecasting

  • Time-consuming: Gathering input from multiple stakeholders can be time-consuming, especially if stakeholders are geographically dispersed or have conflicting schedules.
  • Potential for groupthink: Consensus forecasting may be susceptible to groupthink, where individuals may be reluctant to challenge the consensus or offer dissenting opinions.

Advantages of non-consensus forecasting

Non-consensus forecasting involves generating a forecast based on the expertise of a single individual. Advantages of this approach include:

  • Faster: Non-consensus forecasting can be faster than consensus forecasting since it does not require input from multiple stakeholders.
  • Greater flexibility: Non-consensus forecasting may be more flexible since the individual generating the forecast can adjust it quickly based on new information or changing circumstances.

Disadvantages of non-consensus forecasting

  • Greater susceptibility to biases: Non-consensus forecasting may be more susceptible to biases such as overconfidence or confirmation bias.
  • Potentially less accurate: Non-consensus forecasts may be less accurate than consensus forecasts since they do not reflect the expertise of a broader range of perspectives.

When to use each approach

Consensus forecasting is generally recommended when accuracy is critical, and the outcome being forecasted is complex and multifaceted. Non-consensus forecasting may be more appropriate when speed and flexibility are more important than accuracy or when the outcome being forecasted is relatively simple. Ultimately, the choice between forecasting methods will depend on the specific needs and objectives of the business.

VI. Conclusion

Consensus forecasting is a powerful tool for businesses looking to generate accurate forecasts and make more informed decisions. By leveraging input from multiple stakeholders and fostering open communication and collaboration, businesses can mitigate individual biases, improve forecasting accuracy, and ultimately drive success.

Recap of key takeaways

  • Consensus forecasting involves gathering input from a diverse group of stakeholders to arrive at a shared forecast.
  • Consensus forecasting can lead to improved accuracy, better decision-making, and greater mitigation of individual biases.
  • Non-consensus forecasting may be faster and more flexible but may be more susceptible to biases and less accurate.

When it comes to implementing consensus forecasting, it's important to establish clear objectives, foster open communication, and leverage technology to facilitate the process. By doing so, businesses can improve forecasting accuracy, make more informed decisions, and ultimately drive success.

We encourage businesses to consider adopting a consensus forecasting approach in their decision-making processes and to explore how this approach can benefit their operations.

Demand Forecast Chart

See How ifm Can Support Your Supply Chain Improvement Initiatives

Shorten your learning curve, make the most of your organization's data and resources, and maximize supply chain process improvements across business functions.

View Solutions 
Watch Video